press.nz

PoliticsLaw

Luxon must replace three senior ministers by 4 December, before any coalition deal

The circular, tiered Beehive building with a flag on its roof, seen from above on an overcast day, with a Norfolk pine in the foreground
The Beehive, the Executive Wing of New Zealand's Parliament, in Wellington Ballofstring (wikimedia, CC BY-SA 4.0)

Christopher Luxon has until 4 December to appoint a new finance minister, Attorney-General and Justice Minister, London Daily News reports. That means the caretaker prime minister must fill three of the most senior jobs in government before coalition talks have properly started.

Nicola Willis, Chris Bishop and Paul Goldsmith all lost their seats at the election, and London Daily News reports that the Constitution Act lets ministers who are no longer MPs stay in office until the official declaration of results, due on 3 December. They then get one more day to step down. In total, 19 portfolios have to be reallocated.

The three are leaving because of how the party vote fell. National dropped to 29 per cent, which left it with no list MPs, so ministers who lost their seats can't come back on the list.

The legal deadline comes before the political one. 1News reports that parties are waiting for the special vote count, due on 27 November. On provisional results, National, ACT and NZ First hold 67 seats, a majority of two. B2B News reports that the writ is returned on 3 December and Parliament must sit by 14 January 2027. Otago University law professor Andrew Geddis told that outlet "there is no legal deadline by which a government must be formed after an election".

Willis now holds finance only as caretaker, and choosing her successor puts Luxon in the middle of a dispute between National and ACT. Finance is the hardest of the three jobs to fill. On 9 November Luxon said the finance minister would be a National MP, London Daily News reports. The Spinoff reports that he has called this "non-negotiable".

ACT leader David Seymour, an associate finance minister, has rejected that. He told the NZ Herald, as quoted by The Spinoff, that ACT had been "a little bit kind" in talks after the last election, and that it was now "no longer tenable" for National to expect one of its own MPs to hold finance. "All politics aside and you were just managing an organisation, then the obvious person to fulfil a role would be the person who had been deputising in the role," he said.

The other side has its own plan if the special votes change the numbers. Labour wants Barbara Edmonds as finance minister, and Chris Hipkins has ruled out giving the job to Greens co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick, according to The Spinoff.

That deadline also runs up against the caretaker convention. B2B News summarises the Cabinet Manual's caretaker rules this way: when it is unclear who will govern, significant, controversial or long-term decisions, including major contracts and senior appointments, should be deferred. If a decision can't wait, ministers must use temporary holding arrangements or consult across the House.

In this case the law doesn't let the appointments wait. Luxon has not said publicly whether he will use a holding arrangement, such as spreading the portfolios among ministers who kept their seats, or whether he will consult ACT, NZ First or the opposition before making the appointments.

The convention leaves him some room. Law News quotes it directly: "there are no hard and fast rules. Ministers may need to take into account various considerations (including political considerations), in deciding whether it is appropriate or necessary to proceed on a matter."

The convention itself began with a fight over finance. Law News reports that it came out of the 1984 standoff, when outgoing Prime Minister Sir Robert Muldoon, who was also Finance Minister, refused to devalue the dollar as incoming Prime Minister David Lange wanted. Muldoon gave in within two or three days.

Sources

  1. Luxon faces 4 December deadline to replace New Zealand finance minister
  2. How the different parties are positioning themselves for coalition negotiations
  3. Caretaker government 2026: what stalls for NZ business
  4. Opportunity's Wong meets Luxon and Hipkins
  5. Who's in charge of running the country if coalition negotiations drag on?