press.nz

PoliticsLaw

Luxon says Willis stays as finance minister until a new government. Law professor says she must go on 4 December

The round, tiered Beehive building in Wellington seen from above and behind, with the city and harbour beyond under a blue sky
The Beehive in Wellington, New Zealand, seen from the Reserve Bank of New Zealand building Ballofstring (wikimedia, CC BY-SA 4.0)

Nicola Willis lost her seat at the election. Christopher Luxon says she remains finance minister anyway, under caretaker rules. On Sunday he said, in remarks reported by interest.co.nz: "Caretaker provisions mean that Nicola will carry on as finance minister until the new government is sworn in, as you understand and know."

Andrew Geddis, a law professor, gives her a much earlier exit date. He told Briefs.co that ministers who lost their seats "are entitled under our Constitution Act to remain in office until the official declaration of the election results". MPs are formally declared on 3 December. Geddis said the Constitution allows one more day after that for any minister who is not an MP to step down. On his reading, Willis's last day is 4 December.

Special vote results are due on 27 November, according to interest.co.nz. Luxon has said he will only start formal coalition talks once official results are declared, Briefs.co reported. If talks wait for the 3 December declaration, Luxon has one day before Geddis's 4 December cut-off. On that timeline, a new government will not be sworn in by 4 December.

If Geddis is right, Luxon has to give the finance portfolio to a sitting MP before any coalition deal exists. Luxon's Sunday remarks don't mention a 4 December deadline or say who would take over finance from that date.

Finance isn't the only portfolio affected. Briefs.co reported that Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith also lost his seat and, like Attorney-General Chris Bishop, who is trailing in Hutt South, is serving in a caretaker capacity. Briefs.co counts 19 portfolios between the three ministers, though Bishop's are at stake only if he loses Hutt South. "All of those warrants are going to have to be distributed to someone on December the fourth," Geddis said, "but they'll then have to go away and negotiate who exactly should hold them long term."

The finance handover also tests a promise Luxon has already made. In the same Sunday remarks he said: "that finance minister will be a National Party person, as I've said before, that's not negotiable." Interest.co.nz reported he was answering speculation that ACT leader David Seymour could take the job now that Willis is out of Parliament. Luxon didn't name Seymour, but a National-only rule shuts him out.

Seymour told the NZ Herald, in comments carried by interest.co.nz, that Luxon's position was "no longer tenable". "Everything's negotiable, Christopher," he said. Seymour argued that one of the government's remaining associate finance ministers should take the role in the caretaker period. "All politics aside and you were just managing an organisation, then the obvious person to fulfil a role would be the person who had been deputising in the role," he said.

That pool is thin. Bishop trails Labour's Ginny Andersen by 889 votes in Hutt South, according to interest.co.nz. If he loses, Seymour and NZ First's Shane Jones are the remaining associate finance ministers. Neither is a National MP. Under Seymour's approach, Luxon would have to give way on finance before talks even began.

ACT won 10.92% of the party vote and is projected to have 13 seats, according to Electoral Commission figures reported by interest.co.nz. NZ First won 9.78% and is projected to have 12. A majority in a 120-seat House is 61.

Briefs.co reported that before the vote Seymour said it was "very possible" he would go for the finance job if it came free, and that Luxon's statement had also prompted talk of Simeon Brown or Erica Stanford as contenders. The Herald's pre-election campaign diary named Brown as a key contender, "as a Luxon loyalist and a focused numbers man". It said Bishop would have the strongest claim if he held Hutt South.

If Labour leads the next government, finance spokesperson Barbara Edmonds would take the portfolio, according to Briefs.co.

Interest.co.nz reported that new National MPs did not respond when asked whether any of them wanted to be finance minister.

Sources

  1. New MPs' first day, Luxon's finance promise and the who's who behind the Opportunity scenes
  2. Luxon must name NZ finance minister by Dec 4
  3. Election 2026 Campaign Diary: Who would replace Nicola Willis as Finance Minister?