press.nz

EducationLaw

Abbey Caves coroner tells Ministry of Education to improve school trip guidance

Elevated view over Whangārei city, its harbour and marina, with green hills in the distance under a clear blue sky
Whangārei, seen from Mount Parahaki Lisa Conze (wikimedia, CC SA 1.0)

A coroner has found that a 2023 Whangārei Boys' High School caving trip on which 15-year-old Karnin 'Tino' Petera drowned should have been cancelled, and that he would not have died in those circumstances had it been. Coroner Alexander Ho wants the Ministry of Education to improve its guidance to schools.

According to 1News, his findings, released on 5 November, recommend clearer criteria for cancelling school trips and changes to how MetService presents weather information.

Tino drowned on 9 May 2023 when his outdoor education group was caught in a flash flood in Abbey Caves. Sixteen other boys and two adults got out. An orange heavy rain warning was in force for Northland that day. The inquest was held in Whangārei in April and May this year.

The school already had a rule that should have stopped the trip. Its risk assessment said any heavy rain warning would mean cancellation, 1News reported. The planners decided the Northland warning didn't apply specifically to Abbey Caves. They went with hourly forecasts that predicted lighter rain.

Ho called this an "overly optimistic risk tolerance", particularly because the students were inexperienced cavers.

On the morning of the trip, Tino's father, Andre Petera, phoned the school to report flooding in central Whangārei. That message never reached the group. The coroner couldn't establish whether it would have changed the outcome.

He did not blame the two adults underground. Ho found the teacher and the external instructor "did their best" to keep the boys safe, and that the death was "no reflection" on what they did inside the cave.

The Principals' Federation president told RNZ on 6 November that schools need help monitoring weather conditions and more advice on calling off activities.

Neither the Ministry of Education nor MetService has publicly responded to the recommendations.

A WorkSafe investigation found multiple failures contributed to Tino's death and concluded it was preventable. In September 2024 the school's board was ordered to pay more than $500,000 in reparations, 1News reported.

Tino's parents, Andre Petera and Alicia Toki, said they hoped the coroner's recommendations would be implemented. "His death was entirely preventable," they said.

At the inquest, Toki said: "We trusted our son would be safe at school."

Sources

  1. Fatal school trip should have been cancelled after weather warnings – coroner
  2. RNZ Education