Commerce Commission says 25-year-old tower-sharing rules should go
The Commerce Commission has recommended scrapping the rules that let mobile operators put their equipment on a rival's towers. Its reason is that the operators no longer own the towers.
The Commission's final report recommends removing the regulated mobile co-location service from Schedule 1 of the Telecommunications Act. The existing rules stay in force until Media and Communications Minister Paul Goldsmith decides, so for New Zealand phone customers nothing changes yet.
Co-location means a mobile operator installs its own network equipment on a shared tower. That saves building a separate tower and cuts the cost of extending coverage, the Commission said in its release. The regime dates from the Telecommunications Act 2001.
"When mobile operators owned the towers, they had little incentive to give competitors access," Telecommunications Commissioner Tristan Gilbertson said. "The rules addressed that risk by allowing operators to use a competitor's tower rather than building their own."
The rules did real work. According to Reseller News, the regime played an important role in supporting competition, including 2degrees' eventual entry into the mobile market.
Then the market changed. Spark, One NZ and 2degrees sold their tower portfolios to specialist companies including Connexa and Fortysouth. Connexa and Fortysouth don't run mobile networks, so the rules don't apply to them, the Commission said.
Gilbertson argues the new owners want tenants anyway. "We found no significant barriers preventing access to mobile towers," he said. "Tower companies have strong commercial incentives to attract existing operators and new entrants."
The Commission's main evidence is the three years since the tower sales. Since then, access has been negotiated commercially, and the Commission said it found no sign of competition problems in that time. "Removing the rules would better reflect how the market has operated since mobile operators sold their towers three years ago," Gilbertson said.
Removing the rules takes away the fallback an operator could use if a rival operator refused a deal.
Gilbertson said the Commission would keep monitoring the sector and could still step in if competition problems emerge, Reseller reported.