House values fall for a seventh month and are no higher in real terms than a decade ago
House values fell 0.4% in October, the seventh monthly fall in a row, according to Cotality's index, reported by RNZ. Cotality put the national median value at $790,987. That's 2.3% lower than a year earlier and 19.1% below the January 2022 peak.
The ten-year view is flatter. Cotality said the national median rose an average of 3% a year over the past decade, or 34.7% in total. Stats NZ's consumers price index rose about 34% over the same period. After inflation, a typical home is worth about what it was ten years ago.
Auckland has done worse than that. "Auckland's only had 1 percent growth on average over the past 10 years," Cotality chief property economist Kelvin Davidson said, as reported by RNZ. He blamed some of that weakness on the new unitary plan.
In October, Cotality's figures showed values holding steady in Hamilton, Tauranga and Christchurch. Dunedin slipped 0.1%, the ODT reported. Auckland fell 0.7% and Wellington 0.9%.
A split down Cook Strait
OneRoof's own valuation data shows the same north-south divide. It measures something different from Cotality: an average value rather than a median. The two sets of figures can't be compared directly.
On OneRoof's measure, the national average is $955,000, down $7,000 over the past three months and $9,000 over six.
Otago's average rose 0.8% over winter to a record $1.065 million. Canterbury gained 0.4% to $821,000.
The Wellington region's average dropped 2% to $817,000, its lowest since Covid. Wellington City fell 3.2% to $902,000, below where it was at the start of 2020. Auckland's average slid 1.3% to $1.236m, close to $300,000 below the market peak, OneRoof said.
Over winter, 52 suburbs reached record values. All of them were in the South Island, mostly in Christchurch. Another 41 suburbs, largely in Wellington and Auckland, fell back to pre-Covid levels. On OneRoof's figures, no Wellington suburb has gained value over the past three years, while every Christchurch suburb has grown.
OneRoof's analysis says lower prices have been "a boon for first-home buyers, but few others". In many markets first-home buyers are now the main force, it said, while investors have mostly stayed out despite the return of interest deductibility.
Buyers have the upper hand
Davidson said the balance of power still lies with buyers in most cases. The stock of unsold homes is high, and the spring rise in listings is underway.
Few owners are being forced to sell, though. Davidson put mortgagee sales at about 400 in the past year. At the worst point after the global financial crisis, there were more than 2,600.
He said sales volumes drifted lower through the year, and that sales and prices could stay sluggish for the next 12 to 18 months. The Cotality index came out in the days before the 7 November election. "Whichever way the election goes, a cautious view about house prices seems warranted," Davidson said.
He suggested the old pattern may not return: "maybe we've already moved into the new normal where growth is lower and people are changing the way they might be thinking about property investment."
REINZ's October figures are due in mid-November. They will be the first sales figures since the election.