press.nz

Politics

Wellington councils apply to keep iwi votes on Tiaki Wai committee as 18 November date nears

Aerial view of a city centre with large retail buildings, car parks and a railway station beside a motorway, with green hills behind
Aerial view of Porirua City Centre and Porirua Station, New Zealand D Coetzee (openverse, CC CC0 1.0)

Porirua and Hutt City councils have voted to apply for a government exemption that would let the two iwi representatives on Tiaki Wai's oversight committee keep their votes. Without those votes, Wellington City Council would be able to block decisions backed by every other council that owns the region's water authority.

Upper Hutt and Wellington City councils were due to decide at extraordinary meetings on Wednesday and Thursday. Greater Wellington Regional Council decides next week.

The applications respond to a letter Local Government Minister Simon Watts sent to mayors and regional council chairs in September. Infrastructure News, which reported the councils' applications, said Watts told them non-elected members of council committees, such as mana whenua and youth representatives, would lose their voting rights from 18 March 2027. He asked councils to apply for exemptions by 18 November, next Wednesday.

Watts set a high bar. "The Government's policy is that non-elected members should generally be non-voting," he wrote, as quoted by Infrastructure News. "Councils seeking an exception will, therefore, need to demonstrate a clear and specific justification that supports the statutory test that the exception is necessary or desirable." In June the government said these voting rights lacked "democratic accountability".

The councils' case depends on how the votes are split. Tiaki Wai's partners committee is made up of elected members from its five shareholding councils, plus two mana whenua representatives: Helmut Modlik of Ngāti Toa Rangatira and Amelia Vinnell of Taranaki Whānui. Dame Kerry Prendergast chairs the committee as an independent but has no vote.

There are 10 votes in all. Wellington City holds three and Hutt City two. Porirua, Upper Hutt, Greater Wellington and each iwi representative hold one. A special resolution needs a two-thirds majority, and that majority must include most of the councils and iwi representatives.

With the iwi members voting, the four smaller councils and the two iwi representatives together hold seven of the 10 votes. That is enough to pass a resolution even if Wellington City votes against it. Without the two iwi votes, Wellington City's three would be enough to block any resolution the other councils support, Infrastructure News reported.

Lower Hutt councillor Simon Edwards, who represents Hutt City on the committee, said the iwi members' contribution was practical. "Their input is helping the rest of those on the partners committee in a very real way to get what is in the interest of all ratepayers, to try and keep costs down and to make progress on dealing with the infrastructure backlog," he said, as quoted by Infrastructure News.

Other councils are applying too. Christchurch City Council is seeking exemptions for four of its committees. They include its audit and risk committee and the committee overseeing regeneration of the Ōtākaro Avon River Corridor.

Watts, who is also caretaker Climate Minister, will attend COP31 in Antalya from 15 to 18 November, RNZ reported. He will be overseas on the date he set.

The government's post-election guidance, as summarised by b2bnews, says caretaker ministers keep full executive authority but are expected to defer significant decisions where they can, or to consult other parties where they can't. Official results are due on 27 November and the writ is returned on 3 December.

Whether exemption decisions count as significant enough to wait for a new government is an open question. So is who will assess the applications, and when councils will get an answer; the reporting on Watts's letter doesn't say.

Sources

  1. Wellington councils apply to keep mana whenua votes on Tiaki Wai committee
  2. Council pushing back against new laws banning unelected people voting on its committees
  3. Council ignores staff, mana whenua advice on voting rights
  4. Council ignores staff, mana whenua advice on voting rights
  5. Councillor struggles to see logic behind voting rights change
  6. The young Kiwis heading to the world's biggest climate change gathering
  7. Apec Shenzhen summit lands before NZ election results