press.nz

Economics

Jobs shock cuts market odds of a December OCR rise to about 50%, but big banks keep their forecasts

A multi-storey office tower with some floors lit, photographed at night from the street, with traffic lights and light trails in the foreground
The Reserve Bank of New Zealand building in Wellington at night Clilly4 (wikimedia, CC0)

Market odds of a Reserve Bank rate rise in December fell from 80% to around 50% after Wednesday's jobs data, ANZ senior economist Matthew Galt estimated. Interest.co.nz reported the figures. ANZ, ASB and BNZ are keeping their forecasts anyway, though ASB and BNZ say rates may rise more slowly.

Unemployment hit 5.7% in the September quarter, up from 5.6%. Economists had forecast 5.4% to 5.6% and the Reserve Bank 5.5%, BusinessDesk reported. BNZ senior economist Doug Steel said employment fell 0.1%, when the market had expected a 0.4% rise and the RBNZ 0.3%.

The official cash rate (OCR) is 2.75%, and economists disagree on where it goes next. ANZ expects rises of 25 basis points, or 0.25 percentage points, at each of the next three meetings. ASB's Mark Smith expects "a steady pace of 25 basis point hikes and a 3.5% OCR peak by March 2027, but we acknowledge risks are skewed to more gradual tightening". BNZ is sticking with a 3.75% peak, reached through four straight 25-point rises, though Steel said "today's data increases the chance of more pauses along the way". NZIER expects only one more increase, in late 2027, trade publication MPA reported.

Kiwibank argued that further hikes aren't needed while the labour market keeps a lid on price growth, according to MPA. Before the data, Kiwibank was forecasting a move to 3%, then 3.25% in 2027, MPA reported. It isn't clear whether the new argument amounts to a formal change of forecast.

After the release, Westpac senior economist Michael Gordon said the details looked soft from the RBNZ's perspective, "an important consideration ahead of the 9 December Monetary Policy Statement, as there are few other major data releases between now and then", BusinessDesk reported. Gordon said members of the Reserve Bank's Monetary Policy Committee who favour holding would take this as a sign that the jump in inflation is unlikely to spread to other prices and wages. Westpac chief economist Kelly Eckhold had gone into the release expecting a 25-point rise in December and an eventual 4% peak, while warning that "a December hike is not a done deal", interest.co.nz reported.

One vote could decide it. On 28 October the committee held 4-3, with Governor Anna Breman, Carl Hansen, Prasanna Gai and Rebecca Williams voting to hold, and Paul Conway, Hayley Gourley and Karen Silk backing a rise, MPA reported. ASB said markets had put the odds of a hike at around 95% before that announcement.

The hold didn't close the door. All seven members agreed further tightening would likely be needed, news service Finwire reported. Breman told reporters afterwards: "We think it's likely that we will do further increases at [the] coming meetings."

The case for waiting rests on the jobs numbers. Wage growth was 2.1%, in line with the RBNZ's projection, Steel said. But he said the employment and unemployment figures "must raise questions around the pace at which the [Reserve] Bank will lift its cash rate ahead". BusinessDesk quoted Kiwibank economists saying the October hold "feels more and more justified". Kiwibank's economists also said "we expect the peak in unemployment is still ahead", interest.co.nz reported.

The case for moving rests on prices. The RBNZ lifted its December-quarter inflation forecast to 4.4% from 3.9% on higher fuel costs, Finwire reported. Citing RBNZ figures, Smith said items making up 56% of the CPI basket, by weight, had price increases of 3% or more. He said the central bank is likely to be wary of higher consumer prices filtering into wages. Galt said "the RBNZ can't afford to have the labour market also become a source of CPI inflation", though he added that spare capacity suggests little risk of that any time soon. He also said job numbers tend to turn after the wider economy does, so the RBNZ has to look at inflation risks and signs of recovery as well.

The currency adds to that side of the ledger. The New Zealand dollar fell to 55.85 US cents at 11am in Wellington from 56.13 just before the release, BusinessDesk reported. A weaker dollar can make imports dearer for businesses and shoppers. Finwire said Chinese currency moves and a strong US job openings report may also have weighed on the kiwi.

Two views on mortgage rates, both given before the data, point in opposite directions. Cotality chief economist Kelvin Davidson said that with the OCR still heading up and global wholesale rates elevated, mortgage rates could rise further. Kiwibank argued that as markets wind back expectations of a 4% OCR, wholesale rates should fall and ease the pressure on mortgage rates.

Eckhold said a December rise would depend partly on inflation expectations. The RBNZ's survey of inflation expectations is due on 17 November, according to Finwire. The decision itself comes at 2pm on 9 December.

Sources

  1. 'We expect the peak in unemployment is still ahead' - Kiwibank economists
  2. Unemployment rate hits 5.7%, putting December OCR hike in doubt
  3. NZ unemployment hits 11-year high
  4. New Zealand Jobless Rate Jumped in Q3: Next RBNZ Hike in Doubt?
  5. Split RBNZ holds OCR at 2.75%, but economists still tip December hike
  6. RBNZ's Christmas present to NZ will be an OCR hike in December, BNZ's Stephen Toplis says