Migrant workers can challenge job fees paid overseas, Employment Court rules
Migrant workers can challenge fees they paid overseas to secure New Zealand jobs, the Employment Court decided on 8 October, RNZ reports.
The judgment, which covered two cases including Labour Inspectorate v Top Produce Ltd, found that charging workers such fees breaks section 12A of the Wages Protection Act 1983. It overturned a 2003 ruling.
Charging someone for a job, known as a premium, was already explicitly illegal when the money was paid in New Zealand. Payments made offshore were a grey area.
One case involved Top Produce, a now-defunct Bay of Plenty kiwifruit grower. The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) accused it of asking incoming migrant workers to pay for a job. Top Produce went into liquidation in March with a $1.5 million tax debt.
The court heard the requests were informal, made by phone or text, with little or no protection for the worker.
A passage quoted in RNZ's account of the court material calls the location of the payment "a calculated feature of the exploitation model, designed to evade domestic regulation and to trap vulnerable workers in debt bondage before their employment even begins". Payments are commonly made by bank deposit to the employer's offshore accounts, or to accounts held by the employer's relatives, generally with little or no documentation. The aim is to avoid tracing, the report says.
The published account of the case leaves three things unclear: whether the employer, a recruiter or someone acting for them is liable, what the outcome was for individual workers, and whether an appeal has been lodged.
Lisa Meto Fox, an employment lawyer based in South Auckland, told RNZ she felt deeply encouraged by the decision, which she said "closes a loophole that these bad-faith actors were exploiting".
"These bad-faith actors were making a lot of money," she said. "We're talking up to $60,000 per worker per job in New Zealand."
"The law in this area needs to be expanded further to make it unlawful to be required to pay for recruitment expenses such as flights, visas, vaccines, insurance - that would be consistent with international human rights law," Fox said.
She said the decision had prompted discussions in the legal community about how the judgment may be carried forward, and that workers under the Recognised Seasonal Employer (RSE) scheme could be a future focus. RSE workers currently pay for all of those recruitment expenses, Fox said, and the cost takes a significant portion of what they earn here. "I am on the record talking about [the RSE Scheme] being akin to modern slavery," she said.
PMN reported 198 complaints about premiums to the Labour Inspectorate in 2025/26, following 270 in 2024/25 and 391 in 2023/24, according to a published account of Official Information Act data. That account calls this a "stark increase", but the figures as printed fall each year, and it doesn't settle which is wrong.
MBIE had not recorded complaints from RSE workers about premiums specifically, PMN reported. Fox said it was rare for migrant workers to complain themselves, because they are wary of being deported.
Concerns about migrant exploitation can be reported to MBIE on 0800 200 088 or through its online form. Interpreter support is available.