Bay of Islands Hospital lost an evening transfer ambulance, and senior doctors say 111 cover is paying for it
On 1 July, Hato Hone St John withdrew one Kawakawa-based ambulance that ran patient transfers from Bay of Islands Hospital from 4pm to 12.30am, seven days a week, the Northern Advocate reported.
The cut is months old. What's new is a warning from the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists (ASMS), the senior doctors' union. It calls the current arrangement "incredibly inadequate" and says it could slow responses to 111 calls.
St John and Health New Zealand disagree about why the ambulance went.
St John told the Advocate it made the cut to match the funding Health NZ has available. It said staff shortages were not the reason. Chris Haines, St John's national operations manager for patient transfer services, said the organisation "has the capability to provide additional PTS capacity should Health NZ commission and fund further services".
Alex Pimm, Health NZ's group director of operations in Te Tai Tokerau, said Health NZ had not reduced its funding for patient transfer services.
The two statements don't have to contradict each other. A contract that stays the same size buys fewer hours when costs rise. The Advocate reported that it was unclear whether Health NZ had increased funding to cover the past year's rise in transport costs. Neither organisation has said what the contract is worth.
Doctors see the effect in the emergency department. Patients at Bay of Islands Hospital are often sent to Whangārei for CT scans, surgery or other advanced care, and these transfers are very common, said ASMS branch president Dr Eugene Fayerberg. The ED has seven acute beds and two consult rooms. Fayerberg said patients who need a non-urgent transfer after hours now wait until 7am the next day, which, he said, ties up beds and lengthens waits.
Urgent cases can still go by frontline ambulance. ASMS industrial officer Sarah Thompson said doctors at the hospital after hours must choose between longer ED waits and taking an ambulance away from the community.
"If it's anaphylaxis or major heart attack, the time for paramedics to get to the patient could be increased and care delayed," Fayerberg said. He wants the old service brought back, or a Health NZ in-house service started immediately.
Neither St John nor Health NZ has released 111 response times for the Mid North since July, or a count of after-hours transfers held until 7am.
Pimm described the cover that remains. Transfer ambulances are available to Bay of Islands Hospital from 8am to 8pm every day, with some extra services outside those hours. Time-critical urgent transfers are available 24 hours a day. Health NZ has also made more use of air transport to support road ambulances in Northland.
Health NZ's longer-term answer is to run its own vehicles. It is buying patient transfer vehicles for Te Tai Tokerau, but they are not expected on the road until autumn 2027.