press.nz

CultureEconomics

Mayors urge Stuff to keep its regional reporters ahead of decision on cuts

A man stands on a printing press walkway in a dim industrial hall, reading a freshly printed newspaper
A worker checks a printed newspaper at an industrial printing press Somogro Bangladesh (pexels, Pexels License)

Two mayors, a business chamber and a National MP have asked Stuff to keep the journalists it plans to cut from its regional newspapers, RNZ's Mediawatch reported last week. Staff consultation closed on 13 October. Stuff has not said what it will do.

"We are still working through the process with our people and won't be commenting further," a Stuff spokesperson told Mediawatch.

The mayors' appeals are the first public pressure from outside the newsroom since consultation ended. Nelson mayor Nick Smith said: "I recognise the financial pressures on Stuff but hope a way can be found to maintain the critical mass needed." RNZ notes that his city's paper, the Nelson Mail, has come out four days a week since 2017 and lost reporters in a 2022 restructure.

Palmerston North mayor Grant Smith asked Stuff to keep journalists at the Manawatū Standard. "Local knowledge ... and the ability to be present when something happens cannot easily be replaced by remote coverage, contributed material or imagery sourced elsewhere," he said, according to RNZ.

Amanda Linsley, chief executive of the Manawatū Business Chamber, raised the same concern about pictures. "Local photos and videos also help people feel connected to what is happening in their own community," she said. "Reducing the (visual) team to one person will inevitably mean less local coverage."

The Standard has already tried this. Its visual journalist Warwick Smith told the NZ Herald's Media Insider column that going from two visual journalists to one was "untenable". He said the paper tried it three years ago and it didn't work, and that he worked alone for six months during a hiring freeze.

In September, Rangitata MP James Meagher wrote on Facebook that he was "disappointed ... Stuff is proposing to reduce the number of reporters in regional New Zealand, particularly at the Timaru Herald." But he drew a line at public money: "While I'm not a fan of taxpayers subsidising media, I do believe in paying for good content and making the choice to support local."

Stuff has suggested the opposite. "Government, and local government too, must evaluate their role in the importance of local journalism as the costs of paper, print, energy and distribution of newspapers rise significantly," a spokeswoman told the Herald.

What would go

Stuff said in September that it planned to "streamline" newsgathering to make its regional news more sustainable. The union E tū told the Herald that up to 18 roles are at stake: four reporters, four visual journalists, five print producers, a designer and four other newsroom roles.

Reports differ on which papers are affected. RNZ lists Manawatū, Wairarapa, Nelson, Timaru and Southland. Waatea News lists six regions and adds Taranaki.

In Southland, reporter and E tū member Louisa Steyl told the Herald the Southland Times would be left with three reporters to cover 34,000 square kilometres. Waatea reports E tū's claim that Stuff's newspapers already have no reporters based in Otago, Tauranga or the East Coast.

E tū says the proposal leaves the number of pages and print days alone and cuts only people. A roving regional team would be halved to two, the union says, and those who stay would start writing for Neighbourly News, "Stuff's new hyper-local feed, which relies heavily on AI." Stuff recently launched 18 free Neighbourly News sites carrying stories from its journalists, readers and other local sources, RNZ reports. E tū also says that less than a week after announcing the proposal, Stuff advertised for copywriters to write sponsored content for the same papers.

Waatea says regional reporters are often the ones covering whenua development and how Treaty settlements are being put into practice. Fewer of them, it says, could mean fewer journalists at hui or looking into concerns raised by hapū and iwi, at a time when Māori media outlets are under heavy financial pressure themselves.

The union's offer

E tū's assistant national secretary Mat Danaher told RNZ that journalists have offered to work with Stuff on a new plan for regional news. "Stuff should take them up on it and drop these cuts. Every one of these voices is asking for the same thing: keep local reporters in local towns." He first offered a "real plan" in the Herald.

Hundreds of people have signed a letter by Stuff journalists warning that the plan could turn established mastheads into "zombie papers", according to E tū. The letter is addressed to chief executive Sinead Boucher, who bought Stuff from Nine for $1 in 2020.

Stuff says it employs about 300 journalists and publishes 13 daily and weekly newspapers. In July, Stuff Digital, its joint venture with Trade Me, said up to eight editorial roles could go.

A Koi Tū paper by former NZ Herald editor-in-chief Gavin Ellis found that NZME and Stuff had closed about 40 community titles in seven years. On the spread of news deserts, Ellis wrote: "We stand ankle-deep in encroaching sand." NZME owns the Herald and competes with Stuff. A 2024 Spinoff survey estimated New Zealand had about 1400 journalists left.

Danaher told the Herald: "A Facebook group can tell you there's a pothole. A reporter asks why it's been there for six months, what the council promised, and who made the call."

Sources

  1. Mediawatch: Stuff urged to shelve cuts to regional journalism
  2. Media Insider: Stuff plans to cut 18 journalism roles in regional and small-town NZ
  3. Regional Newsrooms Under Threat as Stuff Proposes 18 Job Cuts Across Aotearoa