press.nz

Politics

Opportunity will talk to National first, then Labour if talks stall, Wong says

The round, tiered Beehive building in Wellington under a clear blue sky, with the New Zealand flag flying from its roof
The Beehive, Wellington, New Zealand Michal Klajban (openverse, CC BY-SA 4.0)

Opportunity will start coalition talks with National and turn to Labour only if those talks go nowhere, leader Qiulae Wong said after meeting both major party leaders for the first time.

"If they are willing to talk and want to talk, then we will have those discussions with them, but if it feels like we're not reaching any agreement or can't move that forward, we will certainly speak to Labour," Wong told 1News.

Before this week, Opportunity's only commitment was to speak first with whichever party won the most seats. Wong told 1News that the special votes, due on 27 November, were unlikely to change that order, "given that National's got a much larger number of seats."

On provisional results reported by 1News, National, ACT and NZ First hold 67 seats, one more than the 66 needed for a majority. Labour, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori hold 56, and Opportunity has seven MPs. The Spinoff reported that the Hamilton East and Wairarapa seats could flip from National to Labour, and that the specials are expected to bring the left further wins.

Wong met Christopher Luxon for an hour on the evening of Monday 9 November and Chris Hipkins for an hour the next day, 1News reported. Neither meeting was a negotiation. RNZ reported that on 9 November Wong said she wanted to meet every party leader but ruled out negotiations until after the final count.

Wong told 1News the Hipkins meeting was about "understanding each other's priorities a bit more, and just getting to know each other as people, seeing as we're new parliamentary colleagues." An Opportunity spokesperson told RNZ the pair talked "generally" about the campaign and "everyone's desire for more collaboration and positivity".

With Luxon, Wong said, Opportunity's five bottom lines came up only broadly; they didn't discuss them in detail or whether National would meet them. Luxon's decision during the campaign to rule Opportunity out didn't come up at all. "We didn't discuss it," Wong told 1News. "I think, ultimately, the fact that we've landed at a place where more political leaders are looking to find those areas of common ground is a good outcome for New Zealand."

She said she and Luxon bonded over their private-sector backgrounds, sustainability and business, and she told him she saw sustainability and business as "the biggest opportunity for New Zealand's economy". Luxon called it a very positive and constructive conversation. "It was a great opportunity to get to know her and start to build a relationship together," he said, according to 1News. National chief of staff Cameron Burrows and Opportunity chief of staff Iain Lees-Galloway also attended.

The Spinoff, writing before the Hipkins meeting, listed Opportunity's bottom lines. They are powers for the Commerce Commission to force structural separation of anti-competitive businesses such as the supermarket duopoly, a mandatory lobbyist register with a cap on party donations, a 10-year cross-party health plan, phasing out bottom trawling, and recommitting to the Paris Agreement. Its land value tax is not among them.

According to The Spinoff, the bottom line Hipkins is most concerned about is bottom trawling, and Labour doesn't dispute that the practice is harmful. "It all comes down to a question of how," Hipkins said.

Within each bloc, the parties also disagree over who should be finance minister. Luxon has called a National MP in the finance portfolio "non-negotiable". David Seymour told the NZ Herald that expectation was "no longer tenable", The Spinoff reported. On the other side, Labour wants Barbara Edmonds in the job, and Hipkins has ruled out giving it to Green co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick.

Wong was due to meet Swarbrick on the evening of 10 November, RNZ reported. The same day she "bumped into" Te Pāti Māori members outside a gym, and they swapped contact details to arrange a later meeting, the spokesperson told RNZ.

On 8 November Swarbrick said it was time for Opportunity to "pick a side". Former Labour leader Phil Goff told RNZ's Morning Report the party would be "in trouble" if it sided with the right, The Spinoff reported. "Ultimately, that is a decision for us," Wong replied.

The spokesperson told RNZ that Opportunity had heard nothing from NZ First leader Winston Peters or ACT's Seymour "at this stage". RNZ noted that NZ First has previously ruled out working with Opportunity. Wong has said she is seriously considering ruling out NZ First after Peters's comments about Green MP Lawrence Xu-Nan.

New ACT MP Paul Henry told RNZ on election night that if Luxon didn't speak with Wong, Seymour would urge him to.

Sources

  1. Opportunity's Wong meets Luxon and Hipkins – what we know so far
  2. Opportunity's Qiulae Wong meets with Chris Hipkins
  3. How the different parties are positioning themselves for coalition negotiations
  4. New Zealand's New Party Meets Both Rivals